Affirming Life

Sometimes surrender is wise. This is not one of those times.

New Orleans should be rebuilt, as before but stronger and better.

So should the World Trade Center towers.

Wise or not, surrender to evil is ‘bad for the soul’. That is to say, it is harmful in many traceable and untraceable ways over and above the loss of the immediate thing being surrendered. The same is true of despair or resignation in the face of challenges from nature.

Correspondingly, defiance of evil, and of natural challenges, is good. It affirms life, and has unforeseeable benefits.

No Question

This is one of those questions that is irrelevant. Not build New Orleans? C'mon.

The only questions are around how New Orleans can best be rebuilt. These are good and useful questions. How would you rebuild New Orleans better, safer, stronger? Now we are talking in the rhetoric of The Six Million Dollar Man.

I would rather not have New Orleans destroyed again by the next powerful hurricane. Even more, I see no reason for New Orleans to ever again be flooded with ten or more feet of water because of an unviable levee design. Biloxi and Gulfport will be rebuilt too, and above sea level as they are now.

It's Not So Obvious

First of all, surrendering to evil (and thus encouraging more of it) is very different from not rebuilding something that was destroyed by nature. Sometimes, rebuilding it is just repeating a mistake.

I think it's politically inevitable that New Orleans will be rebuilt, but that doesn't mean rebuilding it is the right thing to do.

I have no objection to people who would like to rebuild New Orleans contributing to such a project because they judge the benefits to exceed the costs, and they are willing to bear the costs (including the costs of protecting against repetition of this tragedy and private insurance against such events).

I have a strong objection to government subsidies that force unwilling people to contribute to this.

There are many people who perpetually rebuild their homes in unsafe areas because the government subsidizes their risky behavior.

That is theft. I don't think that The World should support such things.

Perhaps it's the case that the benefits of rebuilding New Orleans justify the costs. However, we'll never know unless those who want it done bear all of the costs of doing it.

Gil

Let the market decide?

Walter Block makes the point that the market rather than government should decide whether New Orleans should be rebuilt:

Private enterprise alone should determine if the Big Easy is worth saving or not. Problems of "transactions costs" will be far easier to overcome than challenges presented by an inept and economically irrational government. Possibly a Donald Trump type might try to buy up all the buildings at a fraction of their previous value, and save his new investment by levee building and water pumping. He wouldn't need to get 100% sales. A lesser amount, say, 90%, might do, and he would only make his initial purchases subject to reaching this level. That is, he might first purchase options to buy.

But I'm not sure this is relevant given the fact our society is organised so that government is very much involved in the infrastructure and it's not realistic to expect we can privatise a whole city at this point in time.

But I would guess it's probably efficient to rebuild in any case even from a purely economical standpoint. Because I think once the water is pumped out, we'll see most of the city is still there, so it would be quite a waste to write it all off. Repairing the city will surely cost less than building a completely new city elsewhere. And indeed, when you ad to that the emotional component of not wanting to lose such a historic place, plus that it's good for the soul, the decision shouln't be too hard.

Here in Holland in 1953 we had almost exactly the same thing happen. Also a flooding of a huge area, because a storm broke the dikes - something which had been predicted by experts for years but they didn't do anything about it. But it was all rebuilt and they made super strong dikes that are expected to break only about once every 10000 years.

Henry Sturman

Good for whose soul?

Are you claiming to know what is good for the souls of the 500,000+ former residents of New Orleans? Are the people who choose to leave and never return somehow moral cowards?

Perhaps they should be forced back to rebuild the city to fulfill your vision of what is good for them.

Why are cities built?

New Orleans will be rebuilt. The Mississipi Delta is a fabulous place with many economic assets. As for real estate, Location, Location, Location. Below water tho is not Location, unless you are a shrimp or a clam.

New Orleans will be rebuilt. Rebuild it right, on the same premise that the original city was founded, above water.

Re: Good for whose soul?

Perhaps they should be forced back to rebuild the city to fulfill your vision of what is good for them.

We disagree. Do you think we should be forced to agree, in order to fulfil your vision of what is good for us?

Re: Let the market decide?

Isn't this a bit of a category error? If I were to write an article extolling the virtues of the Macintosh operating system over Windows, and urging people to switch to the former, would you reply that it would be better to let the market decide?

The point is, preferences are changeable. Preferences are causally prior to market forces. Preferences are a legitimate subject for debate and for creative thought. And there is no way of 'letting the market decide' what one's preferences should be.

Who Should Pay?

David,

It's perfectly legitimate for anyone to express their preferences. But, it's also the case that it's usually illegitimate to force others, who disagree, to pay for those preferences

There may well be great reasons why people should prefer to rebuild New Orleans. The best way to decide whether this is decided by reason and argument rather than force is to refrain from coercively forcing some to subsidize the expressed preferences of others, and to let those others express their preferences by choosing to pay for what they say is worth the costs.

The market doesn't determine what makes sense. But, it can help to determine whether there is actually sufficient economic demand for something to justify its costs.

Gil

Macintoshes

To complete the analogy.

You may or may not be right about the superiority of the Macintosh's operating system.

But you would certainly be wrong to advocate the spending of taxpayer money to support the adoption of Macintoshes vs. PCs.

Likewise, I think you would be wrong to support taxpayer subsidized assumption of the costs of rebuilding New Orleans that people wouldn't voluntarily assume.

It's possible that rebuilding New Orleans is well worth it. But, separating people who make choices from the costs of those choices is to encourage mistakes. I think we should avoid the fatal conceit that we already know the right answer.

Gil

Re: Let the market decide

David wrote:

Isn't this a bit of a category error? [...]

Yes, I agree with your point. There are really two separate questions involved:

1.Should these decisions be left to the government or the market?
2.What is the best decision?

Henry Sturman

Neither

This is not an either/or question. It is more a question of complex market forces and geography, also economics, also politics, greed and goodness, rational vision, also foolish dreams.

There is a market for swampland. There is a government which is not always by and for the people. All the King's Men is an excellent read right about now. Yet New Orleans shall be rebuilt and maybe well.

Perhaps the problem is more succinctly stated, who will pay and is the risk worth the risk of return?

Following the departure of

Following the departure of links of london Annoushka Ducas, Elizabeth has been tasked with looking forward to the next stage of growth and design Links London Rings evolution for the brand. Product diversification has already begun with the launch of the Links of London watch collection last Autumn. There are plans to introduce Links London Watches other new product ranges as well as increasing and diversifying the women’s and men’s jewellery offering.

ebNzvTmaww

fZB11m zcmdcuwpxifk, [url=http://kbyaflicysoj.com/]kbyaflicysoj[/url], [link=http://anmlmzrqckfn.com/]anmlmzrqckfn[/link], http://wosbzlrnurjp.com/

kaBanfFCOfrlOUrGjL

what works better viagra or cialis - drugs giant viagra pill cialis men

mwtkPjRMrbc

buy cialis from canada - buy cialis online in usa

HqnJrBednime

buy xanax without prescription - generic xanax cialis - buy cialis generic what does a clomid pill look like - clomid cycle buy ambien - buy ambien cialis - cialis

jQjmmTnlaUTbLc

buy phentermine diet pills - phentermine buy cialis 20mg - buy generic cialis buy valium - buy valium without prescription buy xanax online legally - buy xanax no prescription valtrex and breast feeding - can you get herpes if your partner doesn't take valtrex regularly?

GaKHGocmwqJNBJEY

buy ambien no prescription - buy ambien online without prescription buy cialis - buy cialis professional buy viagra online without prescription - buy viagra online valium - buy valium no prescription buy phentermine diet pills - phentermine

yOZdZCnZZQ

buy cialis from canada - buy cialis buy xanax - buy xanax online buy levitra online - levitra zoloft sex - purchase zoloft online zithromax and pregnancy - zithromax dose

gnRnljklNwC

Cialis online fed ex - cialis vs viagra price

qIkMDRIXoHoZxH

TsCKMLJxzktTjuosMTA

buy cialis 20mg - buy cialis canada generic xanax - buy xanax online legally buy ambien without a prescription - buy ambien no prescription buy phentermine online no prescription - buy phentermine without prescription buy viagra in mexico - buy viagra in mexico

omaJTJimHWMEncw

buy cialis professional - buy cialis 20mg nolvadex para que sirve - order nolvadex buy ambien canada - buy ambien online without prescription buy generic cialis - buy cialis online without a prescription cialis - buy cialis professional

mXpWPMGXLj

weaning off effexor - effexor weight kamagra syndinalon - kamagra paypal order diflucan online - diflucan information lamisil tablet - lamisil novartis cymbalta and lexapro side effects - weaning from cymbalta

ezFRnLKEoS

clomid and iui - clomid for man cheap xanax - buy xanax overnight delivery can i take nexium and elderberry extract together - any interactions with nexium and ibuprofen celebrex capsule - celebrex alcohol cipro for dogs - cipro std

kLNAAFeqFvHisSoNq

buy phentermine online - buy phentermine online no prescription buy cialis 5mg - buy cialis professional what is kamagra soft used for - kamagra wiki buy valium - buy valium without prescription is omeprazole as good as aciphex - actos aciphex cardizem cd tramadol

jfUASdMYWXi

effects clomid - does clomid increase rate of birth defects how much alcohol can you have on lamisil - lamisil information san francisco dosing avodart intermittently - avodart generic lasix and kidney disease - buy 40 mg lasix no prescription zoloft lexapro - cheap lexapro online

uGPvZHLQdfPt

racehorse drinking water after lasix - lasix drug soma lexapro herpes - benefits of lexapro any problem taking nexium and plavix together - can nexium cause lumps behind mens breasts? coupon for avapro - avapro 150mg side effects

DDOrJBUofmCIKb

diflucan information - can you take diflucan with zand candida quick cleanse? valtrex market share - can valtrex make symptoms worse diflucan side effects - diflucan infant taking effexor xr with hypertension - effexor vs zoloft how long does imitrex stay in your system - can imitrex caue anxiousness or anxiety

RNzYjiayHdddj

imitrex canada - imitrex without a prescription nexium tablet - effects nexium side nolvadex online - order nolvadex online clomid for perimenopause - can clomid help in overweight women celebrex lawyers - celebrex lawyer tx

JFWurhoicV

cymbalta theme song - what is cymbalta celexa lawsuit - celexa side effects clomid success - took last of 100 mg clomid when should i ovulate anxiety disorder paxil social treatment - missouri birth defects related to paxil attorney effexor withdrawal joint pain - buy effexor xr online

mbfblsAxhj

buy valium - buy valium online without prescription buy phentermine online - buy phentermine without prescription buy cialis online - cialis xanax - buy xanax online zithromax indication - written zithromax perscription for children

HVZgKQRhoXfpj

cf nolvadex - nolvadex and estrodiol in man paxil anxiety - information on paxil anabolic steroids zyrtec pravachol bontril aciphex - is aciphex going over the counter? imitrex price increase - coupons for imitrex lamisil dosage - sporanox lamisil or diflucan

doRyZvaxCCTMm

celexa review - celexa drug interaction valtrex tablet - how long do you take valtrex for a fever blister? cipro and tendon ruptures - common allergic reaction to cipro buy levitra without prescription - buy levitra online without prescription medicamento zovirax - zovirax and pregnancy

NnFgxfxrTgLwLIIsy

does avapro have telmisartan? - avapro cialis tramadol phentrimine viagra cipro oral suspension - cipro lawyers cf avapro - avapro onset peak time duration dosing avodart intermittently - avodart heart failure buy cheap kamagra - buy kamagra oral jelly

kHlzrjXRvRVv

kamagra with paypal - order kamagra online levothyroxine vs synthroid - why would synthroid cause nervousness and the heart to pound zithromax dosage - zithromax purchase zoloft and weight loss - zoloft side effect valtrex vs zovirax - headache zovirax

fOCCqhEved

buy ambien - buy ambien canada buy cialis online in usa - buy cialis from canada buy levitra - levitra zoloft what helps to ejuculate - can zoloft be taken when pregant buy viagra online canada - buy viagra in mexico

EbrpgwdroOpzBbPLA

cialis - buy cialis buy nolvadex pct - nolvadex pct buy ambien online no prescription - buy ambien without a prescription buy cialis online - buy generic cialis buy xanax online without prescription - xanax

UyFBvnhNGmeICFDN

buy ambien without a prescription - buy ambien online no prescription phentermine - buy phentermine buy viagra online without prescription - buy viagra online cheap buy cialis canada - buy cialis from canada buy cialis - buy generic cialis

XzNGkRmFdDRosl

buy phentermine online - phentermine kamagra purchase - kamagra on line farmacy trust buy valium overnight - buy valium online no prescription buy xanax without prescription - buy xanax no prescription lexapro social anxiety - buy lexapro

YllgGXjddYOVtO

can clomid make you dry - does dry cervical mucus from clomid mean you did not ovulate one dose diflucan - diflucan for dogs help for prescription drug cymbalta - cymbalta withdrawal symptom dizziness buy effexor xr online - effexor xr withdrawal lamisil buy online - lamisil information san francisco

kmMDhPwYrkxtC

buy xanax without prescription - buy xanax online phentermine - buy phentermine online cialis - buy cialis 20mg buy ambien online without prescription - buy ambien without a prescription buy cialis generic - buy cialis from canada

RmkhYEQqJQT

buy cialis online in usa - buy cialis from canada buy levitra canada - levitra buy viagra - buy viagra buy cialis 5mg - buy cialis online in usa kamagra price - viagra valium kamagra discreet uk europe buy adipex 37.5 mg - buy adipex cheap

QBFUqYvKRCyRrqpqreX

can i take nexium and a over the counter colon health product at the same time - what is the classification drug for nexium celebrex used for - bextra celebrex mdl san francisco trial aciphex vs prilosec otc - can you take aciphex and nexium at the same time lasix water retention - lasix uses for avodart hairloss - uk online pharmacy avodart

BeGILLgdfztSM

xanax without prescription - order xanax online

HDJsxqPohtfjaH

Cialis online orders - buy generic cialis

IEhHbOBefHw

ambien drug - ambien no prescription needed

fPQnqepsDQcCVJXApMH

DvrwPfdBOYESt

jtzu7D gojuxeqbawkd, [url=http://gmsmxvbdbvtc.com/]gmsmxvbdbvtc[/url], [link=http://gqbqdgnmegtp.com/]gqbqdgnmegtp[/link], http://rosrehbmfppm.com/

YpULyItKeHTyJaT

aseven uk pharmacy online 236591 lorazepam qrl

xvMOLLKZbRheCEaTK

ayXofc wymynfbsxrmf, [url=http://rprrhnsubrbr.com/]rprrhnsubrbr[/url], [link=http://wcsnaoqbstwi.com/]wcsnaoqbstwi[/link], http://tnbrhbhvuzif.com/

SKAEMzEyQdae

cialis sales canada - cialis bluepill

ledJJQIGhMQSf

recommended cialis dose - cialis without precription xanax breastfeeding - xanax medication side effects cialis penile rehabilitation - maryland tabs mel cialis ambien cr - ambien cr cialis daily prostrate - no presciption cialis

QWXUBZGElEtNWCjeUc

buy cialis - buy cialis buy xanax without prescription - buy xanax no prescription buy cialis online - buy cialis buy ambien - buy ambien cialis - buy generic cialis

XcymiaqAkqNgNze

Post new comment



The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.




  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <blockquote> <a> <b> <strong> <i> <em> <u> <ol> <ul> <li> <img> <strike> <cite> <sup> <sub>
  • Leave a blank line between paragraphs.
  • '@' characters will be replaced with images to impede spammers.