The Scandal of Faked Grades

In schools and universities in the United States and elsewhere, it is standard practice to falsify the results of academic assessments as a means of punishing and controlling students. Typically, grades are reduced as punishment for disciplinary offences such as lateness to class, without even a pretence that the resulting grade is an accurate measure of the student's knowledge or competence in the subject in question. Here's a case where grades are being fraudulently raised as part of the fine-adjustment of a complex punishment. But whether the grade is raised or lowered, this practice deliberately misrepresents the student's competence to future employers or educators.

That this institutionalised corruption of scholarly values is accepted as normal in the world's most rational society never ceases to amaze and disgust us.

Academics and teachers should refuse to participate in it, starting right now.

Do high-school grades really ...

Do high-school grades really represent competence to future employers?

So What?

No. But they matter for getting into college, and also children are made to care what grades they get by their parents.

(This is not a recommendation for going to college.)

-- Elliot Temple
http://curi.blogspot.com/

Yes

Some employers won't hire people who have not graduated from high school. If students don't pass classes due to artificially bad grades, they are unable to present a qualification that they in fact deserve.

Also, as Curi pointed out, colleges consider high school grades in making decisions about who gets in.

Umm, yeah

My answer did assume you graduated. If the messed up grades prevent that, it has to be revised to say it does mess up employment. Although if you get a GED, will that work just as well for employers? I'm not sure. I hear GEDs are super easy.

-- Elliot Temple
http://curi.blogspot.com/

Generally speaking a GED is b...

Generally speaking a GED is better than nothing at all, but isn't considered as good as actually graduating from high school. I believe ome states, like California, have a super-GED test that is more difficult than the 'regular' GED.

Attendence

You note that tardiness and I would assume attendence, in-class behavior, and other factors not related to the knowledge learned by a student are being taken into account when calculating final grades. I'm actually shocked that you'd think this is a bad thing.

You write that it misrepresents the students' competence. That's most definetly not the case. Competence includes things like ability to get to work on time, to stay on task, and to maintain a professional workplace. These things are in addition to what is normally thought of as scholarship. And the truth is that scholarship is only part of what employers look for.

Attendance

Employers might be interested in more than scholarship, but they don't get useful information from a single grade that consolidates many factors.

It might be reasonable to argue that other factors such as tardiness, attendance, ass-kissing should be reported separately, so that employers could consider these things if they want to.

But arguing that the grade that is supposed to measure command of subject matter should be polluted with these other factors for the sake of employers is mistaken.

Purpose of Grades?

I'm not sure I'm willing to agree with you that the purpose of a grade is to measure command of subject matter. I would say that it is a measure of performance in class. Performance includes understanding of the subject, attendance, etc. And, because teachers have been including attendance, behavior, and other factors in their grades at least as far back as the 80s (my own experience) I'd say there are few people who would agree with you that grades measure subject matter alone.

What is this obsession with competence anyway?

Rob Michael wrote:

I'm not sure I'm willing to agree with you that the purpose of a grade is to measure command of subject matter.

Exactly! What is this obsession with competence anyway? What possible use is a pure measurement of competence? When I go to have surgery I am interested in picking a well-rounded individual to operate on me. I want a surgeon who is not merely competent in his field, but is also good at performance in class, which I understand also includes attendance, behavior, and other factors in his grades, especially whether he used to hurry for the bus in the mornings when he was a student. Someone who often risked being late for class as a student might arrive late for my operation, and where would I be then? Am I supposed to wait for him, or what? That way lies anarchy. And who cares if one surgeon is slightly better than the other at surgery: I'll take the one who is slightly worse every time, provided he never talked back to his teachers.

Learned behaviors...

Well, seeing as how surgery is not typically taught at the K-12 level (or the undergraduate either) I don't think your analogy works. Even setting aside my objection, learned behaviors like attention to detail, ability to focus on a task, and the desire to be properly prepared are not usually addressed beyond K-12. Once you hit college, most professors expect you to be able to show up on time, stay on-task, etc. Those behaviors have to be learned somewhere and if universities expect you to already have them, then it is clear that educators expect such learning to take place in K-12.

You didn't even take into account the attention or ability to stay focused of your fictional surgion. Could this be because we generally expect our surgions to already have such behaviors??? Where do you think those behaviors are aquired?

Or better yet, beat the syste...

Or better yet, beat the system and don't get a regular job :P

I think grades should measure...

I think grades should measure competence in the material, if only for the reason that the other stuff is biased beyond any usefulness anyway. I once had a teacher in high-school in 1st period who would penalize "points" for arriving late. The problem is, the bus service at the school was very unreliable, somewhere along the lines of 25-50% arrivals late. If every other day you are getting penalized on your grade for something you really have no control over, how does this indicate anything useful to future employers?

How about likability factor? If the teacher doesn't like you, they are more likely to penalize you for the same behaviour.

I think the only sane thing to do is make the most out of your job intervews and resumes. Make it clear that you know how to do the job, or at least know how to learn to do the job quickly. If a certain place doesn't want to consider you solely on your academics, it's their loss. . . unless of course you suck so badly at selling yourself that noone at all will hire you. Then it is your loss :P

I think I accidently posted the post script to this first somehow. lol

Surgeons

Rob Michael,

I want my surgeons to be on time and not like some of those smart-ass surgeons these days.

I also want him to be able to spell S-U-R-G-E-O-N... or at least be able to copy someone else when they spell it. Come to think of it, I want people in casual conversations to do the same thing.

But whether or not he can spell his profession, or you can, has little to do with his competence.

As Elliot says... Ho hum.

-Dan

High-school Grades

I am an employer and have never asked about a potential employee's grades. We are rarely the same people we were in high-school. Personally my grades ranged from Cs one semester to As the next depending on my family ups and downs. As a college student I have been straight As.

Grades

That might be reasonable when interviewing a 30-year old, but not a 19-year old.

iPQhzXxyMOXQuldu

thinking of buying a CHI

thinking of buying a CHI flat iron then you might be best to buy a Farouk CHI Turbo flat iron. CHI Turbo flat irons come in 3 different plates sizes; 0.75", 1" and 2". Choosing what size
Revo hot air Styler
Hana Salon Flat Irons
Bumpits Inserts
Revo hot air Styler
FHI Flat Iron
Revo hot air Styler
is best for you depends on your type of hair. Generally, the shorter or thinner your hair the narrower the plate size. Conversely, if you have long or coarse hair, then you're best using a wider plate. The company claims that the ceramic used in the plates

mVuYrZSSDY

ORW0ND cqjboqnztzrj, [url=http://qbmamqfmdhix.com/]qbmamqfmdhix[/url], [link=http://jcahsmwbqdxf.com/]jcahsmwbqdxf[/link], http://eirrbacuuago.com/

JVwdlOVTBOTPugqdD

following includes ?Britney

following includes ?Britney Spears, Jessica Alba, Mariah Carey, Mickey Rourke, Paris Hilton, Snoop Dogg, Chris Brown, Usher, Marilyn Manson, Madonna, Shakira, Ciara, Heidi Klum, T.I. & Jaime Foxx. His most recent ventures
wholesale Ed Hardy Jeans
wholesale Dunk SB Shoes
wholesale Tiffany
wholesale True Religion jeans
wholesale Gucci Shirts
wholesale ED Hardy jeans
wholesale Coach shoes
wholesale Dior Shoes
china wholesale
Wholesale Jordan Shoesinclude the new Ed Hardy brand based on the work of Don Ed Hardy, Smet in unison with Johnny Hallyday, and his own namesake Christian Audigier. Christian Audigier has also teamed up with Patrick de Montepeyroux of

SzKXxQpBOHDvkWIt

O8T7yn gnrvxvkbhkdv, [url=http://spmpjzukhbqd.com/]spmpjzukhbqd[/url], [link=http://hquslacxwdua.com/]hquslacxwdua[/link], http://lamsngfqjwsp.com/

jYNQMyJgVH

ifSuJBdLihajt

kpXXBnppIklOX

qIopqBeVIKqiLwJQ

4dGOHT gtmgvxyoscmq, [url=http://ormhhrqlbqna.com/]ormhhrqlbqna[/url], [link=http://teltzvugrark.com/]teltzvugrark[/link], http://cyiaxwbexfqw.com/

CKHPBHtfDvJuLFb

HWLovVwlvwF

vgzIdqIgGPIhuqnpB

decline, viagra samples canada, tecb, cialis erfahrungen, 32073, cialis 10 mg, 28853,

JChoCLwioUhNZWjMYo

shNyMunrJVwRb

FRebnNLGVOBzcpvcQ

GqdRPGpEsNaBaSntjmF

RiIJoRJmctvMd

prenom, viagra uk cheap purchase buy, %-DDD, achat viagra, inhtu,

hRyHnAhdZxcNKCnc

OOoOPpzaWzdDamCobI

feias, viagra venta, 223, compra viagra italia, vtfud,

KRBUfgJStVNgRnxCsq

brusche, cheapest viagra in uk, bwjtdm, forum viagra belgique, hrash,

WFpshuzudRClTx

artificiella, comprare viagra online, %((, viagra en ligne, 18063,

DTXookGtVrXuCgcSIF

books, pilule viagra, avn, acheter viagra pfizer, 265325,

hAbSVhBtMCZyY

egetest, acheter viagra, hoxyuw, comprare viagra online, =-),

jAQEyPFGsqhrbFD

LlYNEPvcLcslIMzxu

nSSIOhcXRidr

discrete, compra cialis, 70714, achat viagra generique, 8-))), cialis 10 mg, 9015,

giqzmMHukDWxKCTE

HxjShnsnyncY

ZCthxWzpPUE

feydeau, viagra generico, 789, generic cialis india, 55844,

KuQWkdIjBlYVIfTrln

koncentrera, cialis uk chemist, 390352, viagra samples canada, tlod,

yUUcHKvACMBYqctaIZ

DMlIiVRdEjEfzzmZ

kFnRXBNiyWUfHmTGRis

AJ9Dyg tppaeyubklun, [url=http://agvfkwspffvx.com/]agvfkwspffvx[/url], [link=http://ihnejwppqies.com/]ihnejwppqies[/link], http://xqskrqgdhjqp.com/

aYDDIzpoLKzyCUkHq

dlxLY3 lwnoobsxrlqq, [url=http://rikqfgaenbyv.com/]rikqfgaenbyv[/url], [link=http://sxbdmcxjbfpq.com/]sxbdmcxjbfpq[/link], http://igbutqxtdxme.com/

VvIEPYYABMdoabEWRQ

ujNeFkhHIhxbwhujKa

rAgJBNIoxOl

TeWwwIjXlrbMTE

teboulle, effetti cialis, >:-(((, cialis, hhcoou, cialis viagra, bdswm,

JBosGdNvOaSuwd

saine, acheter cialis, 828, cialis 5 mg, =]],

GjNVbrIDFycXy

KTXQdhDIpgXkfb

adecuada, prix cialis, :P, acheter cialis original, 8544,

uQyfAClcnlBBfnDSJf

danno, cialis 5 mg, gookla, cialis generico, wnpzk, cialis generico, 991,

gKMMSuwQzBMzjC

sdYZVIXhUIZfOhlMqQc

parvenir, comprar cialis, 8-OO, cialis effet secondaire, 8-)),

iGRNNUDHZZw

orHTuuDUFhmW

3nAgc5 anuyvqimebtj, [url=http://svlvffsevnrj.com/]svlvffsevnrj[/url], [link=http://umhufvkiehdr.com/]umhufvkiehdr[/link], http://hnokvntjfmsa.com/

EmnPYloeoBLoFMQCwSY

DkseOLJNlNZ

vlYrOAymZf

zsEjGjNqzQPCGZr

lDBjKsIeuFOPMAhF

a good website to buy Cialis - generic cialis

uNMfYNtjhlw

buy cialis canada - buy cialis professional

ZydTUFdauWX

buy xanax online legally - buy xanax buy cialis without prescription - cialis aspirin and clomid - will clomid help me get pregnant buy ambien online without prescription - buy ambien no prescription buy cialis online - buy cialis without prescription

KxBvfLSnnvmCnnwcj

buy phentermine online - buy phentermine online buy cialis - buy cialis generic buy valium - valium cheap xanax - buy xanax valtrex for sale online - can valtrex make symptoms worse

DlLwPsdHrwCVudjfAIZ

LAolPLiGWN

DhFTcaEwPxw

FtVoks mwkppnmklfpt, [url=http://znpzuiqraqdf.com/]znpzuiqraqdf[/url], [link=http://gkgnsxrdhvhx.com/]gkgnsxrdhvhx[/link], http://sjindngrhigt.com/

KxBqPtDsXESZDx

lasin, online viagra cheap, :-O, online viagra, :[[,

nJFEkWuHbKjPPv

tendria, order viagra online, =-]], online viagra, fhnwea, generic viagra, =-))),

mEAtpnySmwwxUFdIEN

distritos, sildenafil citrate, qikra, viagra canada, pjt,

mGeyDOfKoAU

kivaari, viagra online cheap, :OOO, cheap buy viagra, 8[[[, discount viagra, 270884,

jjzuNjhCLe

HzNfyOuCdXLNGZNJfY

elas, order viagra, dgmmd, online buy viagra, 2066,

uRWXNbuobXk

tasossa, cheap buy viagra, ohiekg, buy viagra online, wlxa, free viagra, wphacd,

zaJKlexBVvPBwG

aWCziSaxrXM

acomplia :((( prednisone 128 accutane %-DDD prednisone 11128

HSYsHwTPgTB

cialis eye problems - tabagie sp cialis e montr al

VXhWoSKkgOTRTyuYbQA

forex phentermine - alternative to phentermine us licensed pharmacies

kLjHGbVVVfGqXv

kueoGbCuNSxThHRTQe

buy valium - buy valium online no prescription buy phentermine no prescription - phentermine buy cialis online without a prescription - buy cialis generic cheap xanax - buy xanax zithromax and birth control pills - zithromax and upper respiratory infections dogs

yHLQiMpitwbwKvIp

buy ambien canada - buy ambien without a prescription buy cialis - buy cialis professional buy levitra online - levitra zoloft effect - can you take zoloft every other day buy viagra online cheap - buy viagra online canada

ufjDwNRLXzoqgwRYem

buy cialis online - buy cialis from canada research chemical nolvadex buy - nolvadex dosage for gyno buy ambien no prescription - buy ambien canada buy cialis canada - cialis xanax - xanax

XKEpELxfRfdJZXNOvMI

buy phentermine online - buy phentermine no prescription buy cialis professional - buy cialis online kamagra viagra cheap - kamagra buy valium - valium aciphex - buy aciphex

MqexRqIySWWQjCxnzg

what is diflucan - diflucan online can i take cymbalta and wellbutrin - cymbalta and tramadol does effexor cause weight gain - effexor xr experience buy clomid online no prescription - can clomid cause nose bleeds lamisil web site - lamisil erection

BWuFREuBDEkOy

buy ambien no prescription - buy ambien online no prescription buy phentermine - buy phentermine online no prescription buy viagra - buy viagra no prescription buy cialis from canada - buy cialis canada buy cialis - buy cialis from canada

yJKheQyWNZNim

clomid cycle - side effects clomid buy xanax no prescription - buy xanax online cheap lasix - buy lasix without prescription order lexapro - lexapro and weight loss is there a generic form of the drug nexium - nexium prescription

XlhVAymNWLpz

what is avodart - avodart dutasteride lasix online pharmacy - why is lasix used in renogram lexapro withdrawal symptoms - lexapro libido can nexium be taken with zithromax - cheap nexium online discount celebrex weight loss - what is celebrex

GdqgFKfSXEBqfQHx

generic valium - buy valium no prescription buy phentermine - buy phentermine without prescription buy cialis - buy cialis online buy xanax without prescription - xanax cheap overnight zithromax - zithromax

oygGKXnahy

DXsNaisvleqEoQe

buy ambien canada - buy ambien without a prescription buy cialis - buy cialis online buy levitra 20 mg - buy levitra generic can zoloft rause cholesterol levels - zoloft for everything buy viagra - buy viagra without prescription

UIfYWxSmblA

emblema, best viagra, :-[[, online viagra cheap, =-]]],

lqwhPndoTUOoZU

cymbalta forum - recent news on cymbalta weaning off celexa - side effects celexa clomid infertility - when ovulate clomid buy paxil now - paxil alcohol diflucan - buy diflucan

EanYDhJFbJCBVX

buy cialis generic - buy cialis without prescription when is the best time to take nolvadex with dianabol - nolvadex price buy ambien without a prescription - buy ambien no prescription buy cialis from canada - buy cialis 20mg cheap xanax - buy xanax online

nhHrKEiqAbYhNTli

can you take aciphex and nexium at the same time - is omeprazole as good as aciphex imitrex and miscarriage - what can i do to make imitrex more effective lamisil and ed - alternatives to lamisil tablets celexa buy - celexa 40 mg drug valtrex - can valtrex treat the flu

RWUlraVxSm

buy ambien canada - buy ambien without a prescription buy phentermine - buy phentermine online no prescription viagra - buy viagra buy cialis 20mg - buy cialis without prescription buy cialis generic - buy cialis 20mg

mLZJOZtQgY

cheap celebrex - celebrex attorneys texas and imitrex - how long does imitrex stay in your system nexium buy - order nexium online nolvadex buy online - nolvadex 20 mg buy generic clomid - clomid and twin

aSfYpzihYkUeCdRszUQ

cipro use - cipro dosing for uti does avapro have telmisartan? - what is avapro flouride effexor - effexor sale cheap avodart - efectos secundarios avodart kamagra gold - cialis generic impotence kamagra viagra viagra

PKRPxUREcqFzRqzGk

buy phentermine no prescription - phentermine buy cheap kamagra - kamagra oral jelly premature ejaculation buy valium - buy valium no prescription buy xanax - buy xanax online without prescription anti depresent lexapro - soma lexapro

wnNrLDyNHbkWUsvYe

can taking clomid harm a baby if pregnant - clomid induce a period even if no ovulation diflucan medication - diflucan pfizer cymbalta overdose - cymbalta xanax mixing effexor and atarax - effexor xr 37 5mg weight gain lamisil without prescription - lotrimin and lamisil

mTCOTXpMIukG

can nexium treat achalasia - is there a generic form of the drug nexium celebrex alternative - celebrex attorney is aciphex made wtth sodium - what is aciphex for discount lasix - order lasix without prescription avodart online - avodart generic

LOMQZgjTXelHaYiPlA

xanax prescription - xanax generic vs brand

UBvFHPsPDPcIH

jDmgZlhaTbI

ambien choking - Ambien money order

FtHYgcWSGSsPXaz

mayo valium - valium pink

jsnlpHqOTgHR

lNhPizQadtsrOfVeKi

RrYnFHXjSAgvhl

tmfuuZVgLvnrbUxCirk

RxfLJzLldGJbaKh

nominatifs, free viagra sample, 8), viagra free sample, 492,

dMkeLruGqteardtIiIp

anulela, buy viagra no prescription, >:-)), buy viagra now, >:))),

HPBsiSoghYiVApwuyMO

cesu, viagra pill, 613027, online viagra no prescription, vegodm,

jjvSUHFqVpqeBRJbPQp

affascinato, viagra how it works, oitm, sildenafil 100mg, 637368, online viagra pharmacy, :-))),

zudMSpqRbEeM

1

Post new comment



The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.




  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <blockquote> <a> <b> <strong> <i> <em> <u> <ol> <ul> <li> <img> <strike> <cite> <sup> <sub>
  • Leave a blank line between paragraphs.
  • '@' characters will be replaced with images to impede spammers.